Timber VS Masonry Walls: What Is The Best Option?

Timber-framed walls and masonry walls are both excellent options for building exteriors or interiors. Either one of these options can look terrific upon completion and – if properly constructed – should offer good protection from the elements. So which option is the right choice? 

These walls are fundamentally different, which means each offers unique characteristics, advantages, and functions. Let’s compare these two popular building wall materials to determine the best option. 

Characteristics of Masonry Walls in Melbourne

Masonry walls are usually constructed of brick, block, or stone and are often covered with a layer of rendering so that they will appear completely smooth and seamless. 

• Strength – The sturdy materials used for creating these walls lend a lot of strength. So much so, these wall types can even be functional for multi-storey buildings. 
• Durability – Masonry walls can last over 100 years, even with minimal care.
• Repairability – These walls can be very costly and more complex to repair. 
• Resistance – Offers good fire resistance, isn’t likely to rot, and isn’t vulnerable to pests.
• Cost – These walls can be significantly more expensive compared to timber walls.
• Construction time – The construction is more complex and takes longer to properly dry.
• Labour – More skilled labourers are required to avoid structural issues. 
• Sound Isolation – The thick mass offers good noise reduction. 
• Sustainability – Masonry materials like bricks are energy-intensive and emit a lot of carbon dioxide. 

Leading Cons

This type of wall can become brittle and crack if there is structural movement. Masonry walls are also a lot more costly and can harm the environment. 

Characteristics of Timber Stud Walls in Melbourne

Timber stud walls are constructed with a timber framework that creates a skeletal structure for internal partitions or walls. This frame is usually covered with a type of sheeting – usually wood panels or plasterboard. After applying the sheeting and coating it with plaster, the walls can look very similar to a painted masonry wall.

• Strength – Timber does have a greater strength-to-weight ratio and can result in lightweight structures that perform well even during earthquakes. 
• Durability – Greatly depends on care since wood is vulnerable to moisture and insects. With proper care, these walls usually last about 50-80 years.
• Resistance – Wood is combustible, and timber is more vulnerable to moisture and pests. 
• Repairability – Timber is easy to repair because it is so flexible and easy to work with. 
• Cost – Timber is a lot cheaper and isn’t as labour-intensive.
• Construction Time – The walls are very quick to build, especially if they are prefabricated off-site. 
• Labour – Proper installation does require a lot of skill and equipment, but it is easier compared to masonry walls.
• Insulation – Wood naturally insulates the building, but because it doesn’t have the same thermal mass as masonry, it is not as effective as brick walls.
• Sound Isolation – Additional layers of insulation should be installed if you want walls that offer the same acoustic performance as masonry.
• Sustainability – The walls are made from renewable materials and are much better for the environment. 

Leading Cons – More vulnerable to pests, moisture, and fire. 

Contact Wall Experts for Timber Stud or Masonry Wall Repairs in Melbourne

Timber stud walls and masonry walls are both excellent options. Either one of these wall types can be ideal for dividing rooms or expanding your property. If you are looking for the most affordable solution, timber walls are always your best option. If you need something stronger and more durable, masonry can be the ultimate choice. 

At We Fix Walls, we can assist with timber stud wall construction in Melbourne or help restore your old masonry walls so they will look fresh and renewed. Contact our wall experts now and find out more about our services, or book our team so we can help you with some new wall constructions.